There must be something in the air (or this fricking ridiculously cold weather snap that we’re in the midst of), because over the past couple of weeks, I’ve seen shepherd’s pie featured on a bunch of different TV cooking shows. Whether it’s a proper British Sunday lunch or the perfect comforting winter meal, it seems to be everywhere. A recent visit to Matt Murphy’s, our favorite local Irish gastro-pub, the only place where we’ve actually sampled this dish, reaffirmed our need to attempt to make this at home. We didn’t actually order it that night as our table was already filled with fish and chips and a pulled pork sandwich, but the Lovely Suse made me promise that we would make it at home. Soon.
While knowing that this was the sort of meal that you made on a weekend afternoon, not on a weeknight, we set out to do so anyways. However, we spread the work over two nights, making the filling one night, and then making the mashed potatoes and doing the final baking on the following night. Not very challenging, huh? Well, to make things a little more complicated, we decided to make the filling in the 30 minutes between cleaning up from dinner and a Monday night playgroup for George. Could we do it? How would we have time to do all of that chopping and browning and simmering and reducing? Enter the food processor.
We have pretty much every kitchen gadget that you can think of, from immersion blenders to hand-cranked pasta machines to ice cream makers to panini presses. Let’s just say that we did a really good job of registering for our wedding. One of the tools that we hardly ever use, though, is the food processor. I never think to use it, always choosing to do my chopping by hand, using the mortar and pestle, or using the immersion blender. It feels like cheating. In our quest for time saving in the kitchen, it was time to bring out the big boy.
First, we had to get the meat started. Trying to find ground lamb is pretty much impossible at our local markets, and lamb “stew meat” costs more than $10/lb. Luckily, I remembered the half of a leg of lamb that I had in the freezer, so after an overnight defrost, it was time for the food processor’s first test. In went the leg meat, cut into smaller pieces, and after 15 seconds, out came perfectly ground meat. Nice. Into the pot it went to brown. In the meantime, we had to deal with the vegetables. Well, as long as we have it out, let’s see what the processor can do with them, right? In went carrots, parsnips, celery, onions, and garlic. In less than a minute, everything was ready to go. OK, maybe this food processor thing isn’t so bad after all. Once browned, out came the lamb and in went the veggies. After another 8-10 minutes, once they had softened, we deglaze with half a bottle of red wine. Add the lamb back in with a can of cherry tomatoes, a couple of cups of stock, some fresh thyme, parsley, salt, and pepper, bring to a boil, cover, reduce the heat to low, and off to playgroup you go. After simmering away for an hour (George spent the majority of it fending off Billie the Tibetan Terrier puppy who insisted on bopping him on the top of his head until George finally put him in his place and had him bowing at his feet), it had reduced a bit, intensified in flavor, and had filled the house up with some pretty nice aromas. After cooling off, into the fridge it went.
Fast forward to the next night, and it was time to finish things off. Time for some mashed potaters. I’ve tried many different ways of making them over the years, but I’m really digging the current incarnation of them. Skins off, cut into one inch pieces, dropped into cold water, brought up to a boil, and reduced to simmer until cooked through. After a good drain, instead of going back into the pot for a good old mashing, it was time to bring in another favorite gadget: the ricer. A ricer looks like a giant garlic press, and it’s great for helping to make light and airy gnocchi dough. Mashing the potato makes for a pretty heavy finished product, but using the ricer keeps them light and smooth. Just squeeze them with the ricer back into the pot, add milk, butter, salt, and pepper, and it’s time for some pie making!
Here’s the easy part. Ladle your lamb filling into a casserole dish, layer your potatoes on top, and it’s ready for the oven. The best part about the entire dish is the crusty pieces of potato that form in the oven, so having lots of peaks and valleys in your potato layer makes sure that you get lots of them. Feel free to make whatever sort of crop circles you want. In it goes into a 375 degree oven for about 35 minutes, or until the filling starts bubbling up and the top and nice and brown and crusty. Be sure to have a sheet pan underneath your casserole dish to catch any bubbling overflow. You do not want it dripping to the bottom of your oven, burning, and filling it with smoke.
So let’s see, we spent 30 minutes on night one, and probably another 30 minutes on night two. Minimal work, minimal chopping, and oh, did I mention that we actually made enough filling for two or three pies? Yup. The next time we feel like making this, All we need to do is defrost it, make some mashed potatoes, and stick it in the oven. With the right planning, the right tools, and some swallowing of my pride, it doesn’t have to be relegated to weekend nights anymore.