
My earliest memory of lobsters involves a yearly 4th of July party held at the home of friends of my parents. The family would go diving for lobsters in the morning and then bring home to be devoured by the waiting masses in the afternoon. I must have been about 4 or 5 years old and was put in the kitchen with a swarm of live lobsters scampering about on the kitchen floor. Needless to say, this did not affect me in a positive way. Some weeks or months later, I was told, I was seen sleep-running, yelling “The lobsters are after me! The lobsters are after me!” Let’s just say that it took many, many years and hour upon hour of lobster-therapy before I warmed to the idea of eating, let alone cooking lobster.

Fast forward about 25 years and there’s a whole mess of controversy surrounding these tasty buggers. People have always talked of how cruel it is to boil a lobster live, and that they hear the lobsters crying while in the pot (lobsters can’t cry, it’s just the sound of air escaping from their shells), and now Whole Foods has decided that the penning and storage of lobsters is cruel and abusive and has decided to stop selling live lobsters. Not selling live lobsters in New England is like not selling rice in China. It’s just hard to fathom. Not only is lobster utterly delicious, it’s part of the the New England economy. I, for one, love to support local products, and I love to eat lobster. Now let’s talk about my favorite way to eat it: grilled.
I love lobster any way I can get it, but oftentimes, a boiled lobster is overcooked, rubbery, or waterlogged. Not to mention it takes a big huge pot of water and lots of time to get that water to boil. What could be easier than just chucking the whole thing on the grill? Well, it isn’t quite that simple. Lobsters may not be that bright, but any animal knows that when placed on a hot surface, it’s time to run. I suppose you could just close the cover, but the sound of angry lobsters bashing against the side of the grill doesn’t sound very pleasant. Therefore, you have to kill them. Yes, sometimes, you have to kill your own food before you get to eat it. The quickest (and supposedly the most humane) way to kill a lobster is to take a sharp chef’s knife and plunge it through the head, splitting it in half and killing it instantly (props to the Lovely Suse for some splendid action shots. Note the spurt of fluid as the knife goes in!). Flip it around and finish cutting through the tail.

I’ll be honest with you. This isn’t the easiest thing to do, and definitely isn’t for the faint of heart. Some lobsters will twitch and snap violently as their nervous system and muscles shut down, but rest assured that as soon as that knife goes in, they’re dead. Any movement you see after (and you will see movement) is just the muscles and nerves doing their thing. The first time you do it is a little freaky, but you get used to it. I know I have. Now that the tough part is over, the fun begins. Scrape out the tomale (that green stuff) and any roe (darker colored green stuff) and save for later use if you want. You’re now left with two halves of a lobster, just waiting for some heat.

At this point, it’s as simple as brushing with some olive oil, salt, and pepper, and then laying them on the grill, flesh-side down. You’ll want to have the grill on medium heat, as you don’t want to cook the flesh too quickly and make it too tough. The shell will begin to turn red, and the meat will turn opaque and start to get charred after about 4 or 5 minutes. At this point, flip them over and baste with melted butter. Close the lid and let them cook through, about another 5 minutes or so. The claws will take the longest to cook since they’re still encased in the shells, so be sure you give them enough time. When finished, brush with some more butter, and you’re all set. The meat will come out of the tail sections in one easy piece, and get your lobster-crackers out to deal with the claws. The lobster will be perfectly cooked through while picking up some smokiness from the grill.
Have I mentioned that you should also be making your own butter for this? Um, sure. Ok. Right. Seriously, we discovered a few months back that making butter is stupidly easy. If you whip heavy cream long enough, it turns to butter. Get out your electric mixer and get to work.

After about 45 seconds, the cream takes a sudden turn from whipped cream to butter. It’s amazing to watch it happen so suddenly. Simply add salt and taste the best butter you’ve ever had.

For the lobsters, we made a compound butter, which is just butter with other stuff mixed in; In this case, we added chopped fresh chives and oregano from the garden. I know this is a little extreme. Next thing you know, we’re going to be mining our own salt and crushing olives to make olive oil. Ok, we’re a little crazy, but we’re not stupid. It’s easy, it’s a novelty, and it tastes good. So why not?
So there’s your lobster lesson for today. I’m sure I’ve offended some of you (hello vegetarians!), and for that, I apologize. But for those meat eaters in the crowd, you must realize that the food on your plate comes from somewhere. Somewhere along the line, some one had to kill it. Doing that killing for yourself isn’t the easiest thing to do, but it makes you appreciate it that much more. Now go get those knives and start stabbing!